Loyalty in America: What Deserves Our Allegiance?

A GVL Connect conversation about commitment, political identity, accountability, patriotism, and why loyalty may be healthiest when it is anchored to values rather than people.

Joanna Reese
Joanna Reese
March 1, 2026
•
11
min read

I opened our March GVL Connect conversation with an easy question: How many people here value loyalty?

Every hand went up.

Then I asked: How many of you consider yourselves loyal people?

Almost every hand stayed up.

That was exactly why I wanted to talk about loyalty. We use the word constantly (as praise for a spouse, a friend, a family member, an employee, a voter, a citizen, even a customer) without spending much time asking what loyalty actually requires or what deserves it.

Loyalty sounds unquestionably good. But like every American value we are exploring this year, it gets more complicated once we ask what happens at the extremes.

"The question isn't whether loyalty is a virtue. The question is: what deserves our loyalty, and what happens when the person or group changes?"
Joanna Reese

The Aspiration: Commitment That Survives Inconvenience

At its best, loyalty means commitment that does not disappear the moment something becomes inconvenient or stops serving us. It is the willingness to remain faithful to something we believe matters even when doing so costs us something.

That is part of why loyalty feels noble. Relationships would be impossible if we abandoned one another at every disagreement. Communities would struggle if nobody stayed committed long enough to build anything. Causes would collapse if people supported them only when doing so was easy.

But that definition immediately creates another question: loyalty to what?

A person? A family? A company? A political party? A country? A cause? A principle?

Those are not interchangeable objects of loyalty. People change. Organizations change. Political parties change. Institutions can drift away from their stated missions. Even our own understanding of right and wrong develops as we learn more.

So perhaps healthy loyalty cannot simply mean staying with the same person or group forever. It needs an anchor deeper than the group itself.

America Was Founded by Breaking an Allegiance

The American founding gives us an almost perfect loyalty paradox: the people we now call Patriots were, from the British government's perspective, rebels breaking their lawful allegiance to the Crown.

By 1775, King George III had declared the colonists to be in open rebellion. In 1776, the revolutionary leaders went further: the Declaration of Independence announced that the colonies were dissolving their political connection to Great Britain because they believed British rule had violated more fundamental principles. The document says the colonies were "absolved from all Allegiance to the British Crown" after laying out a case centered on rights, consent, and government's obligations to the governed.

Read the Declaration of Independence at the National Archives.

That did not mean all colonists agreed. Loyalists remained committed to Britain, and the Revolution divided communities and even families. That disagreement actually makes the loyalty question more useful: people living in the same place could look at the same conflict and reach opposite conclusions about what loyalty required.

Read the National Park Service on Patriots and Loyalists during the American Revolution.

For the revolutionaries, the decision was radical: they chose to break loyalty to the ruler and political system they had inherited because they believed a higher loyalty (to rights, consent, liberty, and self-government) required it. One of America's founding documents therefore gives us a powerful example of loyalty being reassessed when authority and principle come into conflict.

That creates a useful framework for the rest of this conversation. Loyalty can be admirable when it helps us remain committed to worthy principles. But loyalty becomes harder to defend when preserving the relationship requires abandoning the principles that justified the loyalty in the first place.

Political Loyalty Can Become Part of Identity

Politics gave us one of the clearest examples because many Americans inherit political identity long before they evaluate every policy for themselves.

A 2019 Pew Research Center survey of more than 1,800 U.S. parent-teen pairs found strong alignment between parents' and teenagers' party identification: 81% of Republican or Republican-leaning parents had teens who identified or leaned the same way, while 89% of Democratic or Democratic-leaning parents had teens who identified or leaned Democratic.

Read Pew Research Center's analysis of how political affiliation passes through families.

That does not mean those teenagers will vote the same way forever, nor does it mean parental influence is improper. Families pass down language, religion, traditions, values, sports teams, recipes, and countless other identities. It simply helps explain why political affiliation can feel like more than a set of policy preferences.

Political scientists describe partisanship as a form of social identity as well as a political preference. A major review of U.S. affective polarization found that partisan identity can shape how Americans perceive and feel about members of the other party well beyond individual policy disagreements.

Read the Annual Review of Political Science research on affective polarization in the United States.

This is not a Republican problem or a Democratic problem. It is a human-group problem.

I am nonpartisan. I have no interest in telling anyone which party deserves their vote. What interests me is the moment when party loyalty starts outranking personal judgment, when someone feels obligated to defend a candidate, policy, or behavior they would criticize if the exact same thing came from the other side.

"If my values tell me one thing and my group tells me another, I want my values to win."
Joanna Reese

The Founders Worried About Party Loyalty, Too

This tension is not new. George Washington was deeply wary of political faction. In his Farewell Address, he warned that the "spirit of party" could intensify animosity, distort public judgment, and allow ambitious people to use faction for their own power.

Read George Washington's Farewell Address through Mount Vernon's primary-source collection.

Washington's answer was not the final word on political parties; parties became an enduring feature of American democracy almost immediately. But his concern still raises a useful question: does loyalty to a political organization help us apply our principles, or does it sometimes tempt us to change our principles to protect the organization?

Political parties can organize coalitions, clarify choices, recruit candidates, and help citizens coordinate. Loyalty to a party can therefore be rational and meaningful. The danger begins when the party becomes exempt from the standards we use to judge everyone else.

Accountability Is Not Betrayal

One of the most important turns in our conversation was realizing that loyalty and accountability are not opposites.

In fact, sometimes criticism is an expression of loyalty.

If I care deeply about a nonprofit, I should want it to correct misconduct rather than hide it. If I love someone, I should be able to say when their behavior is harmful. If I value an institution, I should care when it violates its own mission. If I care about America, I should want the country to move closer to the ideals it claims.

That does not mean abandoning people at the first mistake or disagreement. The opposite of blind loyalty is not disposable relationships. People can apologize, learn, change, and repair harm. Institutions can reform. Communities need grace as well as standards.

Healthy loyalty leaves room for both.

It says: I am committed enough to stay engaged, but not so committed that I will pretend harm is harmless or wrong is right.

When Loyalty Becomes a Tool of Control

This became especially personal in our room. Several women described relationships in which the idea of being a "loyal" partner, spouse, or family member made it harder to acknowledge behavior that had become abusive or controlling.

That experience should not be reduced to a simple claim that people stay in abusive relationships because they are loyal. Abuse is far more complicated than that. The National Domestic Violence Hotline identifies many reasons survivors may stay, including fear, financial dependence, children, isolation, cultural expectations, lack of resources, and love. It also describes abuse itself as a pattern centered on power and control.

Read the National Domestic Violence Hotline on why people may stay in abusive relationships.

What our conversation surfaced was the way a virtue can be used against someone. If a person is taught that leaving, questioning, setting a boundary, or exposing wrongdoing is automatically "disloyal," then loyalty can become language for enforcing obedience.

That is not limited to romantic relationships. Families, workplaces, religious communities, political organizations, and other groups can all pressure members to prove loyalty by staying silent.

A healthier test is whether the relationship permits conscience. Can you question? Can you disagree? Can you say no? Can you hold someone accountable without becoming an enemy? If the answer is no, the issue may no longer be loyalty at all. It may be control.

Why Unquestioning Personal Loyalty Is a Democratic Risk

The same distinction matters at the level of political systems.

Political-science research distinguishes institutions that constrain leaders from highly personalist politics, where power becomes concentrated around an individual. Research published in the Journal of Democracy found that increasing personalism in democracies is associated with outcomes including greater polarization and a higher probability of democratic erosion.

Read the Journal of Democracy research on personalist politics.

This does not mean strong admiration for a leader is automatically authoritarian, nor does it mean loyalty to a political figure is inherently unhealthy. The warning sign is the expectation that the person should be protected from ordinary standards of accountability or that loyalty requires followers to stop evaluating evidence for themselves.

American constitutional design offers an instructive contrast. The presidential oath does not require loyalty to a predecessor, successor, political party, or individual leader. The Constitution requires the president to swear to preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution.

Read the presidential oath in the U.S. Constitution at the National Archives.

The object of the oath is an institution and a constitutional order, not a person.

That feels important.

What Does It Mean to Be Loyal to America?

This was where the conversation became most interesting for me personally.

I love this country. I am grateful to be American. I want America to be safe, prosperous, free, fair, creative, and full of opportunity. But I do not think patriotism requires pretending that America is always right.

The entire premise of this 2026 series is that American values are aspirational. Freedom, equality, justice, opportunity, independence, rule of law, and human dignity are directions we are supposed to keep moving toward, not trophies proving that the work is finished.

So to me, loyalty to America means loyalty to that aspiration.

"I don't prove my loyalty to America by pretending America is perfect. I show it by caring enough to help America become more faithful to the values it says it stands for."
Joanna Reese

That also means my concern for human dignity does not stop at a national border. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted after World War II, begins from the premise that dignity and fundamental rights belong to all members of the human family, not only citizens of a particular country.

Read the Universal Declaration of Human Rights at the United Nations.

For me, being American and being human are not competing identities. The larger human commitment gives the national one its moral boundary. I want my country to succeed, but not by requiring me to abandon the human values I hope America itself will champion.

Values Can Compete With One Another

Loyalty also reminded us why none of these monthly values can be examined in isolation.

We may value loyalty to a friend and justice for someone that friend harmed. We may value freedom while also accepting laws designed to protect other people's freedoms. We may value loyalty to family while believing an individual has the right to set boundaries with relatives. We may value national security and also individual liberty.

There is rarely one obvious line that tells us exactly how to balance every competing value.

That is why values require judgment rather than slogans.

Loyalty can help us stay committed through difficulty. Justice can tell us when commitment has become unfair. Freedom can tell us when loyalty is becoming coercive. Civic duty can remind us that our commitments extend beyond ourselves.

The goal is not to discover one value that defeats all the others. It is to build a moral framework strong enough to hold them in tension.

What Are We Teaching the Next Generation to Be Loyal To?

This may be the question I left thinking about most.

I do not know what American political debates will look like twenty years from now. Artificial intelligence alone may transform jobs, education, media, privacy, security, and the way people encounter information. Some of the political categories that feel permanent today may eventually seem outdated.

So I am less interested in teaching children a fixed list of people or groups they should always support than in helping them identify the principles they want to carry into whatever world they inherit.

What does dignity mean? What does freedom require? When does loyalty become complicity? What do we owe someone who is different from us? When should we question authority? When should we stand by someone through a hard season? When does love require a boundary?

Those questions will still matter even if the names of the parties, technologies, institutions, and political fights change.

If we teach the next generation how to examine their own values, they can make decisions we cannot possibly script for them today.

So What Deserves Our Loyalty?

At the beginning of the evening, almost everyone in the room said loyalty mattered.

By the end, we were not less loyal. We were more careful about where we placed it.

Some people talked about areas of life where they wanted to remain more committed. Others recognized relationships, groups, or identities they may have protected long after those things stopped reflecting the values that originally earned their loyalty.

That feels like the real work of loyalty: choosing our commitments consciously instead of inheriting them unquestioned.

For me, the hierarchy is becoming clearer. People matter. Relationships matter. Families matter. Parties, institutions, and countries matter. But none of them should require us to surrender the deeper values that make those loyalties worth having in the first place.

So the question I would leave you with is the one we left Greenville Connect asking ourselves:

What are you loyal to, and what values would make you willing to question the person, group, or institution you love?

Maybe the strongest loyalty is not the kind that never questions. Maybe it is the kind that refuses to abandon its principles when questioning becomes necessary.

Joanna Reese

REALTOR® with Keller Williams Drive

Joanna takes a consultant-first approach to real estate, helping clients sort through complex questions and plan ahead, often long before they are ready to list or buy.