Justice and the Rule of Law: When Legal Is Not the Same as Just

A GVL Connect conversation about order, accountability, civil disobedience, punishment, equal enforcement, and what happens when law and justice pull apart.

Joanna Reese
Joanna Reese
August 1, 2026
•
10
min read

Justice may have been the most personal value we explored at GVL Connect this year.

I am autistic, and I have an unusually low tolerance for injustice. I am the person who walks back into a store if I realize the cashier gave me too much change. If one person is treated unfairly, it bothers me. If I discover an entire system is producing unfairness again and again, it is difficult for me to look away.

But justice is not the same thing as getting even. It is not revenge. And it is not automatically whatever punishment feels most satisfying in the moment.

That is why we paired justice with another American value that can sometimes feel like its natural partner and sometimes its opponent: the rule of law.

"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere."
Martin Luther King Jr.

The Aspiration: Justice and Law Should Reinforce Each Other

A healthy society needs rules. We need to know what is expected of us, what happens when someone harms another person, how disputes are resolved, and whether the same standards apply to the powerful and the powerless.

The federal courts describe rule of law as a system in which people and institutions are accountable to publicly known laws that are fairly applied and independently adjudicated. The World Justice Project similarly emphasizes accountability, just laws, open government, and accessible justice.

Read the U.S. Courts overview of the rule of law.

Explore the World Justice Project's definition of rule of law.

That distinction matters. Rule of law does not mean that whatever a government does is automatically just. The state itself is supposed to be constrained by law, due process, independent courts, and equal standards.

Please Read the Declaration of Independence Again

For this month especially, I want to encourage everyone to go back and read the Declaration of Independence carefully and slowly. Not only the famous sentence we memorized in school. The whole thing.

Read the Declaration of Independence at the National Archives.

The Declaration argues that governments are created to secure rights and derive their just powers from the consent of the governed. It then says that when government becomes destructive of those ends, people have a right to alter or abolish it.

But the document also cautions against changing long-established government for "light and transient causes." The principle is not that anyone who dislikes a law gets to ignore the legal system. The deeper idea is that legitimate authority exists for a purpose and that power is not self-justifying.

America Began With Lawbreaking

The American founding becomes uncomfortable if we pretend law and justice have always been identical.

The Revolution included resistance, rebellion, destruction of property, armed conflict, and a formal declaration that the colonies no longer recognized the British Crown's authority. From the perspective of British law, the revolutionary leaders were rebels.

The National Archives describes the Declaration as an argument asserting a right to revolution after the colonies had defied one of the most powerful governments in the world.

Explore the National Archives explanation of what the Declaration says.

The Boston Tea Party makes the point vivid. Colonists illegally destroyed private property in protest against British policy. Nearly two centuries later, Martin Luther King Jr. invoked the Boston Tea Party while defending nonviolent civil disobedience against segregation.

Read the King Institute's history of Letter from Birmingham Jail.

King's argument was not that laws do not matter. He argued that people challenging unjust laws should do so openly and nonviolently, while accepting legal consequences. His deeper point was that legality and morality are not synonyms.

Justice Is More Than Punishment

That distinction followed us into criminal justice.

When someone commits a serious crime, public safety matters. Victims matter. Accountability matters. There are people whose actions are dangerous enough that separating them from the public is necessary.

But punishment alone does not automatically repair harm.

Restorative justice asks different questions: Who was harmed? What do they need? Who is responsible? What would accountability, repair, restitution, treatment, or reintegration look like?

A Campbell systematic review of randomized restorative-justice conferencing studies found lower repeat offending on average among participants compared with conventional justice alone, along with higher victim satisfaction and lower desire for revenge. That does not mean restorative justice fits every crime or every victim, but it shows that justice can include more than punishment.

Read the systematic review of restorative justice, recidivism, and victim satisfaction.

"Justice should ask what repairs the harm and makes the community safer, not only what punishment feels deserved."
Joanna Reese

Equal Enforcement Is Part of Justice

Rule of law also weakens when the written rule is neutral but enforcement is not.

This issue became personal for me through people I love. A close friend of mine is a U.S.-born citizen from a Cuban American family. He has described encounters in which he felt his citizenship was questioned because of how he looks.

That is his experience, not a dataset, and I am not presenting it as proof of every immigration-enforcement encounter. But it changed the way I hear abstract conversations about enforcement.

The principle should be consistent: investigate conduct based on evidence, apply lawful rules evenly, give people due process, and do not substitute ethnicity, appearance, accent, religion, or political identity for evidence of wrongdoing.

Order and Justice Are Not the Same Thing

Martin Luther King Jr. wrestled directly with this tension in Letter from Birmingham Jail. He criticized preference for order over justice and defended nonviolent resistance to unjust laws.

That does not mean every unpopular law is comparable to segregation, and historical analogies can become irresponsible very quickly. It does mean that legality alone cannot answer the moral question.

A legitimate rule-of-law system needs public rules, independent courts, due process, equality before the law, checks on power, and mechanisms through which citizens can challenge unjust action without having to destroy the entire system.

World War II and the Memory of American Justice

Our conversation also turned to one of the strongest moral stories in modern American identity: the Allied defeat of Nazi Germany.

The history is more complicated than the simplified version many of us learned. Before Pearl Harbor, Americans were divided over whether the United States should enter World War II. The U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum notes that the United States entered after Japan attacked Pearl Harbor and Germany declared war on the United States; rescuing Jews was not the primary reason for entry.

Explore the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum's history of the United States and the Holocaust.

American forces ultimately helped defeat Nazi Germany, liberated concentration camps, cared for survivors, and documented evidence later used in postwar accountability.

Read the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum's history of the liberation of Nazi camps.

For generations, that history helped reinforce an American ideal: national power can be used not only for self-interest, but to stop aggression, expose atrocity, protect human beings, and support accountability.

It is also a reminder that no country permanently owns the role of "the good side." Governments still have to be judged by what they do.

Applying the Same Standard to Ourselves

This is where the conversation becomes more difficult in 2026.

If justice is a value, then the standard cannot apply only to governments we distrust. It also has to apply to governments we support, including our own.

Recent U.S. military actions have produced serious legal disputes that illustrate why independent review matters.

In September 2026, a United Nations-backed fact-finding mission reported reasonable grounds to believe that two U.S. strikes in Iran (including a strike on a primary school in Minab) were indiscriminate and amounted to war crimes. The U.S. administration rejected the mission's conclusions. Earlier U.S. military assessments had indicated U.S. forces were likely responsible for the Minab strike while describing it as a mistake.

Read the Associated Press report on the U.N.-backed findings in Iran.

Human Rights Watch has separately argued that the Minab strike required investigation for possible war-crime responsibility, while also emphasizing that civilian deaths caused by a mistake are not automatically war crimes; legal responsibility depends on facts such as intent, recklessness, target verification, and precautions.

Read Human Rights Watch's legal analysis of the Minab school strike.

The U.S. campaign of lethal strikes against alleged drug-trafficking vessels has also produced international-law disputes. The administration argues it is acting against designated narcoterrorist organizations and has described the operations as part of an armed conflict. Human Rights Watch and other legal critics argue that the legal basis for treating the campaign as an armed conflict is inadequate and have characterized some killings as unlawful.

Read Human Rights Watch's review of the U.S. boat-strike campaign.

A United Nations special rapporteur has argued that the systematic nature of the boat strikes warrants examination under international criminal-law standards. That is an expert legal allegation, not a criminal judgment, and no international court has adjudicated the claim.

The January 2026 U.S. military operation in Venezuela that captured Nicolás Maduro created a similar dispute. The United States described the operation as lawful action against an indicted fugitive. U.N. officials argued that the military intervention raised serious concerns under international law governing sovereignty and the use of force.

Read the U.N. Secretary-General's remarks on the Venezuela operation.

These examples are legally and factually contested. That is exactly why rule of law matters: standards should not change depending on whether we sympathize with the government or people involved.

Independent Evidence Matters More When Power Is Involved

Governments in conflict present their actions in the strongest possible light. Their opponents do the same. Advocacy organizations have perspectives. Journalists can make mistakes. Eyewitnesses may see only part of an event.

The answer is not to give up on truth. It is to demand evidence, transparent legal authority, independent courts, investigators, journalists, inspectors, and review mechanisms capable of challenging official claims.

My personal experiences affect what I notice. So do yours.

Rule of law gives us a better standard than "believe my side." Show the evidence. Identify the legal authority. Allow independent review. Give the accused due process. Protect witnesses. Apply the same standards to allies and adversaries.

Justice Does Not Mean Everyone Follows Personal Law

There is an opposite danger here too.

Once we acknowledge that laws can be unjust, it can be tempting to conclude that everyone should simply follow personal conscience and disregard any law they find immoral.

That cannot sustain a pluralistic society.

The Declaration itself cautions against overturning government for minor or temporary grievances. King's model of civil disobedience emphasized openness, nonviolence, conscience, and willingness to accept legal consequences.

A functioning democracy gives us many lawful tools for change: speech, protest, journalism, litigation, elections, legislation, public comment, organizing, petitions, oversight, and constitutional amendment.

Civil disobedience has a place in American history, but it is not the same thing as saying rules do not matter.

Rule of law without justice can become rule by power. Justice without rule of law can become vengeance or arbitrary personal judgment.

So What Do Justice and Rule of Law Ask of Us?

By the end of our conversation, justice and rule of law did not feel like competing values. They felt like checks on one another.

Rule of law asks us to create stable standards, use due process, restrain arbitrary power, enforce rules consistently, and hold leaders and citizens alike accountable.

Justice asks us to keep examining whether those rules actually protect dignity, rights, victims, and the public good.

When the two drift apart, healthy societies need mechanisms to bring them back together.

Sometimes that means enforcing a law more consistently. Sometimes it means reforming institutions. Sometimes it means repairing harm rather than only punishing. Sometimes it means striking down an unconstitutional law. Sometimes it means citizens organizing peacefully until lawmakers change one.

None of those judgments should be casual. But neither should obedience.

I love America because of our aspirational values. I love America enough to be honest when we are failing to live up to them, because I want to see us do better. To me, patriotism is not pretending America always succeeds. It is caring enough about our founding aspirations to measure our actions against them, hold ourselves to the same standards we ask of others, and keep pushing our country closer to what it has always claimed it wants to become.

Justice is not uniquely American. It is human.

And if we really believe that injustice anywhere threatens justice everywhere, then the work is to build systems strong enough to tell the truth, restrain power, repair harm, and keep moving closer to justice.

Joanna Reese

REALTOR® with Keller Williams Drive

Joanna takes a consultant-first approach to real estate, helping clients sort through complex questions and plan ahead, often long before they are ready to list or buy.