Independence in America: From Self-Reliance to Interdependence
What does American independence really ask of us, and what helps more people actually achieve it?
Independence felt like the right place to begin our 2026 GVL Connect deep dive into American values. Before the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, there was the Declaration of Independence: a document announcing separation from British rule and expressing ideals that would help define the country America hoped to become.
That distinction matters. The Declaration did not describe a nation that had already achieved equality, liberty, or universal self-determination. It described an aspiration.
The National Archives describes the Declaration as expressing the ideals on which the United States was founded. Its most enduring language connects legitimate government to the protection of individual rights (life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness) and to the consent of the governed.
Read the Declaration of Independence at the National Archives.
Like every value we will explore this year, our conversation about independence began with the same questions: What was the aspiration? Who could actually experience it then? What does meaningful independence look like now? And what would move more people closer to it today?
"Independence should mean having meaningful control over your own life. It should not mean being abandoned to figure everything out alone."
Joanna Reese
The Aspiration: Agency, Not Isolation
American culture celebrates self-reliance. We admire people who work hard, solve problems, start businesses, leave home, support themselves, and build lives on their own terms. "Independent" is usually a compliment. "Dependent" rarely is.
But as our discussion unfolded, we realized that the part of independence we actually value is not isolation. It is agency: having enough freedom, resources, information, and power to make meaningful decisions about your own life.
That was also embedded in the founding argument. The colonies were not declaring that they needed no one. They were declaring that a distant governing authority should not control their future without their consent. Their response was not to eliminate institutions or cooperation. It was to build new ones.
The Declaration itself was collective action. Thirteen colonies acted together, formed alliances, organized military forces, created governments, traded with one another, and eventually built a union. American independence was never a story about everyone surviving alone.
Who Could Actually Experience Independence?
This is where the aspirational nature of American values becomes impossible to ignore.
The Declaration proclaimed equality and unalienable rights while slavery remained legal and political participation was restricted. Women did not yet have equal political rights. Many people living on this land had little meaningful control over the laws, property, labor, or institutions shaping their lives.
Over generations, constitutional amendments, laws, court decisions, social movements, and cultural change expanded formal rights and opportunities to people excluded at the founding. That progress has been uneven and incomplete, but it illustrates the pattern at the heart of this series: America often states an ideal before fully living it.
Explore the National Archives history of voting rights in the United States.
So the question is not whether we should return to 1776. The question is whether we are continuing the work the aspiration points toward: helping more people gain meaningful control over their own lives.
When Dependence Becomes Control
There are very real reasons dependence can be dangerous. Our conversation moved unexpectedly from the American Revolution into personal relationships, where dependence can become a tool of control.
Financial abuse is one example. An abusive partner may restrict access to bank accounts, prevent someone from working, take their paycheck, damage their credit, or control public benefits. The National Domestic Violence Hotline describes financial abuse as a form of power and control that can limit a partner's ability to provide for themselves.
Learn more about financial abuse from the National Domestic Violence Hotline.
In that context, independence is not an abstract political concept. It can mean having your own money, transportation, employment, information, housing options, and the practical ability to leave.
Dependence becomes unhealthy when it strips someone of agency. That can happen inside a household, inside an institution, or inside any system where one side has overwhelming control over the choices available to the other.
The Myth of Total Self-Sufficiency
Then our conversation ran into the opposite extreme: what would complete independence actually look like?
The answer, in modern life, is that it hardly exists.
We drive cars built through global supply chains. We eat food grown, transported, inspected, stocked, and sold by other people. We depend on power grids, roads, water systems, hospitals, teachers, farmers, mechanics, technology, financial systems, emergency services, and workers we will never meet.
Even someone living off-grid usually begins with tools, materials, knowledge, medicine, equipment, or technology produced elsewhere.
"If all of us depend on somebody, maybe independence isn't the absence of dependence. Maybe it's having enough agency inside those relationships to still direct your own life."
GVL Connect attendee, reconstructed from the discussion
That was the turning point. The opposite of unhealthy dependence is not radical isolation. It is healthy interdependence.
Interdependence: How Independence Becomes Possible
Interdependence holds two truths at the same time: every person should have as much agency as possible over their own life, and every person relies on other people and systems in some way.
A healthy community does not require every person to contribute the same thing at every moment. Children need enormous support while they grow. Someone recovering from surgery may need temporary help. An older adult may need transportation or healthcare. A person with a disability may need assistive technology or an accommodation in order to work, communicate, travel, or live more independently.
The CDC describes independent living for people with disabilities in terms of voice, choice, and control over everyday life, and notes that assistive technologies can increase functional independence by helping people travel, communicate, learn, work, and participate in community life.
Read the CDC's disability inclusion and independent living resources.
That is an important distinction: support is not automatically the opposite of independence. Sometimes support is exactly what makes independence possible.
A wheelchair can increase independence. A ramp can increase independence. Childcare can increase a parent's ability to work. Education can increase a young person's choices. A temporary safety net can keep a family from losing the stability they need to recover.
The relevant question is not simply, "Did someone receive help?" It is, "Did that help preserve dignity, expand choices, and increase the person's ability to direct their own future?"
When Does Public Support Create More Independence?
This brought us into one of America's most persistent political arguments: public assistance.
The usual framing pits self-reliance against government dependency. But I think that language can obscure what is actually happening.
We often talk about "government money" as if government were a separate entity with a bank account of its own. It is not. Public budgets are built from resources collected from the public and allocated through institutions we elect and maintain. Government is one of the ways a community pools resources to accomplish things together that individuals often cannot accomplish alone.
"Government isn't some separate pot of money. It is one of the ways a community pools resources to do together what individuals often cannot do alone."
Joanna Reese
That does not mean every public program is wise, efficient, or well designed. We should debate how much to collect, what to fund, which level of government should administer a program, what responsibilities recipients should have, how to prevent fraud, and whether a program actually works.
But those are questions about how we use shared resources, not evidence that receiving help is inherently opposed to independence.
Consider a child. A child cannot choose the income of the household they are born into. Providing access to healthcare or education during childhood may look like dependence in the short term, but the more useful question is what happens later.
One peer-reviewed study using IRS administrative data found that greater childhood Medicaid eligibility was associated with higher college enrollment, lower adult mortality, higher wage income for women in the study, lower later use of the Earned Income Tax Credit, and higher tax payments in early adulthood.
Read the peer-reviewed research on the long-term effects of childhood Medicaid eligibility.
That does not prove every social program produces those outcomes, and it does not settle debates about program design or spending. It does show why "help" and "dependence" should not be treated as synonyms. Some investments can increase a person's future independence.
What About Fraud and People Who Take Advantage?
One of the strongest emotional arguments against public assistance is the fear that people will exploit it. That concern deserves an evidence-based answer rather than either dismissing it or exaggerating it.
Fraud exists, and protecting shared resources matters. But fraud is not the same thing as every improper payment or administrative error. The U.S. Government Accountability Office explicitly distinguishes fraud (willful misrepresentation for gain) from improper payments, which can also result from incorrect amounts, documentation problems, or administrative mistakes.
Read the GAO explanation of fraud and improper payments.
That distinction matters because emotionally loaded language can turn every error into a story about laziness or cheating. Better policy requires better definitions. We should identify actual abuse, fix it, and protect shared funds without using the existence of some abuse to erase the legitimate needs of everyone else.
Healthcare Is a Good Stress Test for Interdependence
Healthcare made the interdependence idea especially visible because illness does not stay neatly inside one household budget.
The Congressional Budget Office's 2026 baseline estimates that changes enacted in the 2025 reconciliation law will reduce Medicaid enrollment by about 13.1 million people in 2035 and increase the number of uninsured people by about 7.5 million in 2034. Those are projections, not a claim that all of those coverage changes have already occurred.
Read CBO's 2026 budget and health coverage projections.
At the same time, the same federal law created a $50 billion Rural Health Transformation Program to support rural healthcare systems from 2026 through 2030. That matters because the consequences of health policy are broader than any one insurance card or line item.
Read CMS information on the Rural Health Transformation Program.
Research on earlier Medicaid expansions found an association between expansion and improved hospital financial performance, with substantially lower likelihoods of closure, especially in rural markets.
Read the Health Affairs study on Medicaid expansion and hospital closures.
This is exactly why the independence question is more complicated than "Should one person receive help?" Hospitals, insurers, employers, taxpayers, families, healthcare workers, and patients all operate inside the same system. Removing one form of support does not necessarily remove the underlying illness, need, or cost. It changes where that cost and risk show up.
Reasonable people can disagree about the best healthcare policy. But if independence is the value we are trying to protect, then the test should include downstream effects: does a policy leave more people with meaningful access, agency, and stability, or less?
So What Does Independence Ask of Us?
By the end of our GVL Connect conversation, independence looked different than it had at the beginning.
It was no longer simply "I can take care of myself." It was the ability to make meaningful choices about your own life, to contribute where you can, and to receive support when you genuinely need it without surrendering your dignity or agency.
Interdependence is not a retreat from that aspiration. It may be the structure that allows more people to reach it.
That framework does not dictate a partisan answer to every policy question. Families, charities, businesses, nonprofits, local communities, states, and the federal government can all play different roles. People can disagree in good faith about taxes, eligibility rules, benefits, accountability, efficiency, and which institution is best positioned to solve a problem.
But the value gives us a common test.
Are our relationships, systems, and institutions helping more people develop the capacity to direct their own lives and contribute to the community, or are they leaving people unnecessarily powerless, isolated, or trapped?
That question works in a marriage. It works in a workplace. It works in a family. It works in a nonprofit. And it works when we evaluate public policy.
The American aspiration of independence was never really about needing nothing from anyone. It was about freedom from domination and the ability to shape your own future.
Maybe interdependence isn't a retreat from American independence. Maybe it's how we help more people actually reach it.
Joanna takes a consultant-first approach to real estate, helping clients sort through complex questions and plan ahead, often long before they are ready to list or buy.
