American Values in a Divided America: Can Greenville Find Common Ground?
Why GVL Connect is spending 2026 reclaiming America's founding values as aspirations, and asking how Greenville can keep moving closer to them.
America feels deeply divided. Political parties increasingly seem to inhabit different realities. Conversations about race, gender, religion, government, and community life can quickly become battles over identity. Families avoid certain subjects at dinner. Friends unfollow one another. Neighbors who probably want many of the same things for their families can look across a political divide and sincerely wonder how anyone on the other side could possibly think the way they do.
The explanations we give ourselves are often harsh: they must be ignorant, brainwashed, selfish, immoral, or simply stupid. But the more people I meet, the less convincing that explanation becomes.
Through my work in Greenville, I regularly meet people with very different backgrounds, political beliefs, professions, religions, and life experiences. Underneath those differences, I keep finding remarkably similar hopes. People want to feel safe. They want meaningful work, stable families, opportunity for their children, dignity for themselves, accountability from their leaders, fairness in their communities, and enough freedom to build the lives they choose.
That observation is what inspired the 2026 GVL Connect conversation series.
"I don't think Americans disagree nearly as much about our fundamental values as we've been led to believe. I think we often disagree about what those values actually mean."
Joanna Reese
Instead of spending another year arguing about political issues through vague value language, I want to go underneath them. Before we argue about which policy protects freedom or justice, we should ask what those words mean, where they came from, and what America has historically been trying to move toward.
What does freedom actually mean? What does justice require? Where does independence end and responsibility to our neighbors begin? What does loyalty demand, and when can loyalty become dangerous? What is the value of diversity? What does civic duty ask from ordinary citizens?
Most importantly: can people who disagree politically still develop a shared understanding of the American values they claim to defend?
American Values Were Aspirational From the Beginning
There is one idea I want to carry through every GVL Connect conversation this year: American values have always been aspirational.
The Declaration of Independence did not describe a country that had already achieved equality, freedom, or universal political participation. It declared principles the new nation claimed as its foundation: equality, unalienable rights, life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness, and government deriving its legitimate power from the consent of the governed. The National Archives describes the Declaration as stating the principles on which U.S. government and American identity are based.
Read the Declaration of Independence at the National Archives.
Those ideals were larger than the reality of 1776. Slavery remained legal. Political rights were sharply restricted. The Constitution adopted later did not create universal voting rights. Over generations, constitutional amendments and federal laws expanded formal political rights to people who had originally been excluded, including through the 15th and 19th Amendments, the 24th Amendment, and the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
Explore the National Archives history of voting rights in America.
That progress has never been perfectly linear, complete, or uncontested. But the pattern matters: America repeatedly states an ideal before fully living up to it, and later generations are left to decide what that ideal requires in the world they actually inhabit.
"American values are not a trophy we inherited. They are a direction we inherited."
Joanna Reese
That is what I mean when I say I want us to get back to our roots. I do not mean returning to the social conditions of 1776. I mean returning to the aspirations that gave the American experiment its direction, then asking what moving closer to those aspirations looks like now.
If freedom is an American value, how do we expand meaningful freedom in today's world? If independence is an American value, what actually gives people more control over their own lives? If equality, justice, opportunity, loyalty, diversity, rule of law, and civic duty matter, what would it look like to pursue them honestly in modern Greenville?
That is a very different exercise from asking which political party owns a value. It treats the value as the destination and policy as the debate over how we get closer.
The Problem May Begin With Language
One thing I have become fascinated by is the extraordinary power of words.
Language gives us a way to organize complicated concepts. Once we can name an idea, we can discuss it, remember it, compare it, and pass it to other people. But language can also become a shortcut. A complicated idea can slowly accumulate emotional and political meaning until the word itself begins doing some of the thinking for us.
Consider words like patriot, freedom, justice, equality, woke, elite, traditional, socialist, radical, or even American. Two people can hear the exact same word and attach completely different meanings, emotions, and assumptions to it.
This is one reason I have become interested in the concept of loaded language.
Psychiatrist Robert Jay Lifton identified "loading the language" in his research on ideological thought reform. Dr. Steven Hassan later incorporated the concept into his BITE Model of Authoritarian Control. In the Thought Control section of the model, Hassan describes the use of loaded language and clichés as a way to constrict knowledge, interrupt critical thought, and reduce complexity into simplified buzzwords.
Hassan's larger BITE framework examines four areas through which authoritarian influence can operate: Behavior, Information, Thought, and Emotional control. Importantly, Hassan also cautions that the model should be used as part of a broader evaluation of influence; not every group or relationship uses every technique. (Read Dr. Steven Hassan's BITE Model of Authoritarian Control.)
The relevance goes beyond what we traditionally think of as a cult. The underlying lesson is simpler: language can shape the boundaries of a conversation before we even realize those boundaries have been drawn.
A word can become a signal for who belongs and who does not. A slogan can compress an enormously complicated issue into a moral binary. A label can make us feel as though we understand another person before we have actually listened to them.
That does not mean every slogan, political phrase, or emotionally charged word represents deliberate manipulation. It does mean we should pay attention when language begins replacing curiosity.
Because there is an extraordinarily effective way to influence someone without asking them to abandon their values: convince them that their values require your conclusion.
Someone who deeply values freedom does not want to believe they are opposing freedom. Someone who values justice does not want to believe they are contributing to injustice. Someone who considers themselves patriotic does not want to believe their actions could harm their country. So the argument often becomes an argument over definitions.
"Maybe the question isn't, 'Does that person care about freedom?' Maybe the better question is, 'What do they believe freedom means?'"
Joanna Reese
If two people both value freedom but define it differently, we have something to discuss. If we decide instead that one side loves freedom and the other side hates it, the conversation is already over.
When American Values Become Political Weapons
The challenge is not that Americans no longer have values. The challenge is that many of our most important values have become political territory.
One group claims freedom. Another claims equality. One claims family. Another claims justice. One claims patriotism. Another claims diversity. Over time, values that should belong to all of us can start sounding like partisan brands.
Political strategists, media ecosystems, advocacy groups, influencers, corporations, wealthy donors, and other powerful institutions all have incentives to frame issues in ways that move people. Sometimes that framing informs us. Sometimes it oversimplifies. And bad-faith actors can exploit emotionally loaded language precisely because values matter so deeply to us, redefining words such as freedom, justice, patriotism, or equality until the label itself begins telling us who is good, who is dangerous, and which side we are supposed to join.
The result can be more consequential than ordinary disagreement. Instead of believing that our neighbors interpret a value differently, we begin believing they do not possess the value at all.
If I believe that I value freedom and you do not, I have very little reason to listen to you. If I believe that I care about justice and you do not, compromise begins to feel immoral. If I believe that I love America and you hate it, you are no longer simply a neighbor with a different political opinion. You become a threat.
That is how political disagreement can slide toward dehumanization. Once we stop seeing another person as complicated, sincere, and human, meaningful conversation becomes almost impossible.
What If We Share More Than We Think?
At our first GVL Connect discussion of 2026, we began with a basic question: What values do you associate with America?
The room offered many of the words you would expect: freedom, independence, equality, justice, opportunity, diversity, loyalty, personal responsibility, service, community, and rule of law.
What interested me was not how much people disagreed. It was how much they didn't.
People with very different political identities could agree that freedom matters. They could agree that people deserve opportunity. They could agree that government should operate fairly, leaders should be accountable, families should be safe, and communities work better when people take some responsibility for one another.
The disagreement usually arrived later: how much responsibility? What kind of equality? Freedom from what? Justice according to which standard? Who should be accountable to whom? Loyal to what?
Those are significant disagreements. Finding common values does not mean pretending every policy position is equivalent or that evidence does not matter. But it changes our starting point.
Instead of asking "What is wrong with those people?" we can ask "What does this value mean to you?"
"The point isn't to make everyone agree on everything. The point is to discover how much common ground and humanity is hiding underneath the labels."
Joanna Reese
South Carolina Has Always Been Part of America's Argument About Its Values
These conversations feel especially meaningful in South Carolina because our state has played an outsized role in America's long struggle over liberty, government, power, citizenship, and belonging.
During the American Revolution, the Carolina backcountry became one of the pivotal theaters of the war. The National Park Service describes the Southern Campaign as a brutal conflict that often divided neighbor from neighbor. The Patriot victory at the Battle of Cowpens in present-day South Carolina on January 17, 1781 became a turning point in the war in the South and part of the chain of events that eventually led to the decisive Patriot victory at Yorktown.
Explore the National Park Service history of the Southern Campaign.
Eighty years later, South Carolina again became the site of a defining American rupture. South Carolina had seceded from the United States in December 1860, and on April 12, 1861, Confederate forces began firing on Fort Sumter in Charleston Harbor. The Library of Congress identifies the bombardment as the beginning of the Civil War.
Explore the Library of Congress history of Fort Sumter and the beginning of the Civil War.
Those histories are obviously very different. But both remind us that South Carolina has repeatedly been a place where enormous national questions became intensely local: Who holds power? What does freedom mean? What obligations do citizens owe government? What obligations does government owe citizens? Who belongs fully within the American promise?
Those questions are not relics in a museum. We are still wrestling with them.
Bringing the Conversation Back to Greenville
I believe South Carolinians work hard and care deeply about family, community, independence, faith, opportunity, and the places we call home. I also believe we are just as vulnerable as anyone else to narratives that convince us the primary obstacle to a better life is another group of ordinary Americans.
That is one assumption I want us to challenge.
Our neighbors are not abstract political categories. They are the people teaching our children, starting businesses, repairing our homes, serving food, caring for aging parents, operating nonprofits, attending churches, coaching teams, paying taxes, voting in local elections, and trying to build decent lives.
Whatever happens nationally, we still have to live together locally. And that raises a much more useful question than which political side is winning: what are we trying to build together?
I would like Greenville and the Upstate to be safer. I want more opportunity. I want people to be able to afford to build lives here. I want thriving local businesses, accountable public institutions, strong neighborhoods, good schools, effective nonprofits, and people who feel connected rather than isolated.
I suspect people across almost every political category would say yes to much of that. The difficult (and worthwhile) conversation is figuring out how we get there.
Not Left Versus Right, but Neighbors Around a Table
GVL Connect is not an attempt to create another political umbrella. I do not want everyone leaving these conversations believing the same things or supporting the same candidates. The goal is not to debate, persuade, perform, or win. It is to meet people outside our normal circles and learn how other human beings understand the world. I believe we can build something together without requiring ideological uniformity first.
Maybe that begins with reclaiming some words.
Throughout 2026, each GVL Connect gathering will examine one American value more deeply: independence, freedom, loyalty, diversity, justice and the rule of law, civic duty, and others that emerge from our conversations. We will treat each one not as a partisan slogan, but as an American aspiration.
For each value, we will ask the same basic questions: What was the aspiration? Who could actually experience it when the idea entered the American story? How has our understanding changed? What does the value require in today's reality? And what would move more people in Greenville (and in America) closer to it? We will also ask how values can conflict, how they can be distorted when taken to extremes, and whether our own behavior actually reflects the principles we say we hold.
Because saying that you value freedom is easy. Living consistently with freedom is harder. Saying that you believe in justice is easy. Applying justice even when it benefits someone you dislike is harder. Saying that community matters is easy. Showing up for people outside your own circle is harder.
One Value at a Time
I do not think one monthly gathering in Greenville is going to repair America's political divide. But national culture is ultimately built from millions of local interactions.
It changes when someone sits beside a person they would normally avoid. When a stereotype encounters an actual human being. When someone asks a question instead of making an accusation. When we become curious enough to discover why a reasonable person might see something differently.
And occasionally, something even more interesting happens: we discover that the person we thought was standing on the opposite side was trying to protect many of the same things we were.
Maybe America does not need another group telling us which side is righteous. Maybe we need more tables where people can sit down long enough to remember that we belong to the same community, and a shared vocabulary for the ideals we are still trying to reach.
That is what we are going to explore at GVL Connect this year: not whether America has perfectly embodied its values, but whether we can name those aspirations clearly enough to keep moving toward them: one conversation, one American value, one table at a time.
Joanna takes a consultant-first approach to real estate, helping clients sort through complex questions and plan ahead, often long before they are ready to list or buy.
