Diversity in America: Out of Many, One
Why GVL Connect thinks diversity works best when difference is preserved, people actually mix, and everyone remains part of a shared whole.
For our May GVL Connect gathering, I knew exactly which community organization I wanted in the room. Our American value for the month was diversity, so we invited the Upstate SC LGBT+ Chamber of Commerce to introduce its work. The Chamber describes its mission around helping LGBT+ businesses and professionals thrive in the Upstate while building social and economic equality. Their presence also made our room more visibly varied than usual and gave us exactly the kind of conversation diversity is supposed to create.
Learn more about the Upstate SC LGBT+ Chamber of Commerce.
Every month at GVL Connect, we try to move past the feel-good definition of a value. Freedom sounds good until one person's freedom begins erasing someone else's.
Independence sounds good until it becomes isolation and abandonment of vulnerable people. Loyalty sounds good until loyalty becomes blind obedience, enabling fraud and abuse. Diversity deserved the same treatment; so let's delve in.
"Diversity is not valuable because everybody is different. It is valuable because different people can bring those differences into relationship with one another."
Joanna Reese
The Aspiration: E Pluribus Unum
Diversity is not named in the Declaration of Independence or the Constitution in the way freedom, liberty, or equal protection later appear in our governing tradition. But pluralism has always been part of the American reality, and the tension between difference and unity appeared early in our national symbolism.
The Great Seal of the United States, adopted by the Continental Congress in 1782, carries the motto E Pluribus Unum: "Out of Many, One." The National Archives notes that the motto came from the earliest design work for the seal and ultimately became part of the symbol of the new nation. Explore the original design of the Great Seal at the National Archives.
I love that phrase because it does not say "out of many, make everyone identical." It says one can be built from many. That distinction matters. America's history includes immigration, cultural exchange, religious diversity, regional identities, Indigenous nations, enslaved Africans brought here by force, and generations of newcomers who arrived under dramatically different circumstances. It also includes exclusion, racism, nativism, forced assimilation, and periods when the country failed badly at the very pluralism we now celebrate.
Like the other core American values, diversity has not yet been fully embodied; rather it's been a long, slow work-in-progress since our inception. There have always been individuals who fear "the other" and fight for total assimilation into a homogeneous group, but America would never have achieved global success that way. As leaders stoke fear in their constituents and openly antagonize "diversity", it's time for America to remember the vital role of diversity in building the country we love.
DEI Became a Political Acronym Before We Agreed on What It Meant
Our conversation began in a strange place because, by 2026, the letters DEI (diversity, equity, and inclusion) had become loaded language and political shorthand that mean something entirely different to different groups.
Some people hear DEI and think of removing barriers, broadening recruitment, accessibility, mentorship, or making sure people from different backgrounds can fully participate. Others hear it and worry about quotas, preferences, or people being judged by race or sex rather than merit.
The truth is that DEI is not one standardized program. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission currently describes DEI as a broad term, and it also makes clear that anti-discrimination law still applies: an employer cannot lawfully make employment decisions based on race, sex, or another protected characteristic simply because the practice is labeled DEI. Read the EEOC's current guidance on DEI and employment discrimination.
That nuance matters. A label does not automatically make a program good, and criticism of a specific program does not automatically mean someone opposes diversity itself.
For our conversation, I found it more useful to separate the words. Diversity asks: who is present, and what differences are represented? Inclusion asks: can those people actually participate and contribute? Equity asks: are there barriers that make access or opportunity meaningfully different for different people?
Those are questions we can examine without pretending every policy carrying the acronym DEI is identical, or that the acronym itself tells us whether a specific practice is fair.
America Is Not Really a Melting Pot
For generations, Americans have described this country as a melting pot. The image is understandable: people from different places arrive and become part of something new.
But I have never loved the metaphor. A melting pot suggests that everything is supposed to dissolve into one uniform substance. I do not think that is where America is strongest.
I see America more like a charcuterie board!
There are cheeses and fruits and crackers and meats and nuts and chocolates all packed onto the same board. Some pair beautifully. Some are better on their own. You do not need to combine goat cheese with a chocolate truffle to prove they belong on the same platter.
"I don't want an America where everyone melts into the same thing. I want a country confident enough to let people remain distinct and still belong to the whole."
Joanna Reese
The Statue of Liberty became one of the country's strongest symbols of that aspiration. Emma Lazarus's 1883 poem The New Colossus famously imagined the statue welcoming the "tired" and "poor" who were yearning for freedom. The National Park Service notes that the poem helped transform the statue into an enduring symbol of refuge and immigration, even while that welcoming image often glossed over the real discrimination and difficulty many immigrants faced.Read the National Park Service history of The New Colossus.
That is the same pattern we keep finding in this series: the aspiration can be beautiful even when the country has not always lived up to it.
Diversity Does Not Mean Erasing Culture
I oppose the idea that belonging in America should require cultural erasure. Learning enough shared language, law, and civic norms to function together matters. A pluralistic country still needs common rules and some shared understanding of how we live together.
But assimilation can mean very different things. If it means learning how to participate in American civic life, that is one conversation. If it means abandoning your language, food, religion, traditions, family structure, history, or perspective in order to prove that you belong, I think we lose something valuable.
One of my favorite things about living here is that I can experience pieces of the world without leaving Greenville. I can eat Indian food, Japanese food, Ethiopian food, Mexican food, British food, Korean food, Thai food, and dozens of other combinations shaped by migration and cultural exchange. That is not a failure to become American. That variety is exactly what makes America so great!
Diversity Works Best When People Actually Mix
There is also a research reason to care about differences in the room. Studies of diverse teams do not support the simplistic claim that diversity automatically makes every group perform better. The evidence is more interesting than that.
A 2024 review of team-diversity research found two competing paths. Diversity can create synergy when people exchange and integrate different perspectives. It can also create disruption when people sort one another into social categories, favor people who seem similar, and stop collaborating across differences. Read the 2024 review of diversity and team performance.
That is almost exactly what I have experienced at GVL Connect. A room full of people who already think the same way can feel comfortable, but comfort is not the same thing as insight. When someone enters the conversation with a different profession, race, religion, age, political belief, life experience, or way of thinking, they often see the blind spot the rest of us missed.
But simply placing different people in the same room is not enough. They have to be able to speak. They have to be heard. They have to believe opposing beliefs will not get them expelled from the group.
That is where inclusion becomes essential. Intentionally inclusive practices are apparently the difference between diversity that creates factions and diversity that expands thinking.
Biodiversity Makes the Analogy Visible
Nature also shows that diversity creates greater resilience. The U.S. Department of Agriculture encourages biodiversity and diversified crop rotations because greater biological variety can improve soil function and reduce some disease and pest problems associated with monocultures. USDA research has also found that more diverse crop rotations can reduce risk under poor growing conditions.
Read USDA guidance on biodiversity and soil health.
I like that image because diversity creates more possible responses when conditions change. A system built around one way of doing things can become brittle. A system with different strengths has more options.
Human diversity is obviously more complicated than crop rotation, but the question transfers surprisingly well: are we building communities resilient enough to learn from different strengths, or are we making ourselves more fragile by demanding sameness?
Neurodiversity Changed the Way I Think About Difference
Neurodiversity made this conversation personal for me, because I am autistic and have ADHD. My brain is unusually good at hyperfocused systems analysis, pattern recognition, and following complicated ideas across multiple layers. Those strengths are enormously useful in parts of my work. But the same brain can make social interaction much harder. I can miss cues, interrupt at the wrong moment, wait too long because I am trying not to interrupt, or communicate something more bluntly than I intended.
For much of modern history, neurological differences were discussed almost exclusively through a deficit model: what is wrong, disordered, or missing?
The neurodiversity framework added another lens. The National Institutes of Health describes neurodiversity as the idea that people experience and interact with the world in many ways and that there is no single "right" way of thinking, learning, and behaving. NIH also notes that autism is a neurological and developmental disorder and that people on the spectrum can have a wide range of strengths, characteristics, challenges, and support needs.
Read the NIH explanation of autism and neurodiversity.
That does not mean every neurological condition is simply a harmless difference or that support needs disappear. It means difference and disability are not the same question.
Sometimes a person genuinely needs accommodation or treatment. Sometimes the environment is built around one style of communication and unnecessarily turns difference into dysfunction. Often both can be true at once.
When Diversity Turns Into Tribalism
So where can diversity go wrong? This was the part of the conversation I cared about most, because celebrating diversity without examining its failure modes would violate the whole purpose of this series.
This is where E Pluribus Unum comes back.
Out of many, one.
The "many" matters. So does the "one."
A healthy diverse community needs room for people to remain different and a common identity broad enough to hold those differences together.
For me, that shared identity ultimately has to become larger than race, religion, sexuality, political party, region, or even nationality. We live in a world where people, money, information, disease, technology, supply chains, culture, and climate cross borders constantly. Underneath all of the labels, our largest shared category is human.
"Diversity" becomes less useful when we use the differences to organize ourselves into increasingly narrow identity groups and then stop engaging outside them.
Instead of one charcuterie board, imagine a hundred tiny plates spread across the kitchen: one plate for each race, ideology, religion, political identity, profession, sexuality, generation, or subculture. Everyone feels safe among people who already understand them, but nobody is reaching across the counter. At that point, we have diversity across the room but sameness inside every circle.
That is tribalism, not pluralism.
Technology has made that kind of self-sorting much easier, but the research is more nuanced than simply blaming social media for polarization. A large 2023 Nature experiment on Facebook found that users were commonly exposed to like-minded sources, but reducing that exposure did not measurably reduce political polarization during the study period.
Read the Nature study on like-minded sources and polarization on Facebook.
That finding is useful because it reminds us that our instinct to cluster with people like ourselves is older and deeper than one algorithm. Technology may amplify or organize those tendencies, but it did not invent them. The answer, then, is not to eliminate identity. Identity gives people language, community, history, support, and belonging. The challenge is making sure the circle does not become a new dividing wall.
So What Does Diversity Ask of Us?
By the end of our conversation, diversity no longer felt like a corporate acronym or a demographic checklist. It's more like a practice.
It asks us to intentionally make room for people who are different, without turning difference into hierarchy. It asks us to notice barriers, without assuming identity tells us everything about an individual. It asks us to seek perspectives we do not already have, while refusing to reduce people to the category they represent.
It also asks us to leave our own bubbles. If everyone in your political feed agrees with you, find someone thoughtful who does not. If every person in your professional network looks and thinks like you, widen it. If you belong to a community built around one identity, protect that community. But then make sure you still have relationships beyond it!
We do not need less identity. We need a larger sense of belonging capable of containing more identities at once. America does not need to melt everyone down into one culture. It also cannot survive as thousands of tribes that no longer recognize one another as part of the same people.
Joanna takes a consultant-first approach to real estate, helping clients sort through complex questions and plan ahead, often long before they are ready to list or buy.
